← Resources
Whitepaper

NERC CIP violations 2024–2026: what the public data shows

What follows a NERC CIP violation: usually a Compliance Exception, rarely a penalty, and filings that name no one. Plus the most violated standards.

The short answer

CIP-010, CIP-007 and CIP-004 were the most frequently reported NERC CIP noncompliance in 2024, 2025 and the first half of 2026, with CIP-010 first every time (182, 245 and 125 reports). Most noncompliance never reaches a penalty: about 95% of 2024 dispositions were Compliance Exceptions or Find, Fix, Track and Report. And since 2020, every CIP penalty filing has been non-public, so the entity, the requirement and the amount are not published.

Why there is no list of CIP fines

If you search for recent NERC CIP penalties by company, you will not find them, and that is by design. Since September 2020, NERC asks FERC to treat every CIP noncompliance filing as Critical Energy/Electric Infrastructure Information (CEII) in its entirety, and it no longer publishes redacted versions. The joint FERC/NERC staff white paper that set this out (Docket AD19-18-000, September 23, 2020) gives the reason as "the risk associated with the disclosure of CIP noncompliance information."

Non-CIP penalties are still public, with the entity named. For CIP, the only public view is the aggregate statistics NERC publishes in its Compliance Monitoring and Enforcement Program (CMEP) reports. Everything below comes from those reports, and every number is in the CSV at the end of this page with its figure and page.

Most reported CIP noncompliance

The same three standards lead every period. NERC describes them as standards that "all involve high volume and high frequency conduct": they cover tasks repeated across many devices and people, so a missed date or a missed device is easy to make and easy to find.

Sources: NERC 2024 CMEP and ORCP Annual Report, Figure 6 (p.16); 2025 ORCP and CMEP Annual Report, Figure 6 (p.20); 2026 ORCP and CMEP Mid-Year Report, Figure 5 (p.21). Counts are reported noncompliance at every risk level, CIP top 10 only.

  • 2024 — CIP-010: 182, CIP-007: 168, CIP-004: 166, CIP-003: 133, CIP-006: 100, CIP-002: 69, CIP-011: 31, CIP-005: 27, CIP-013: 18, CIP-008: 12.
  • 2025 — CIP-010: 245, CIP-007: 225, CIP-004: 168, CIP-003: 100, CIP-006: 94, CIP-011: 64, CIP-002: 56, CIP-005: 37, CIP-009: 20, CIP-013: 20.
  • First half of 2026 — CIP-010: 125, CIP-007: 98, CIP-004: 94, CIP-003: 70, CIP-006: 47, CIP-011: 30, CIP-002: 25, CIP-009: 17, CIP-013: 17, CIP-005: 8.

What the most-violated standards ask for

  • CIP-010 — a baseline configuration for each device (operating system or firmware, installed software, open ports, security patches), authorized changes, the baseline updated within 30 days of a change, and for high impact, monitoring at least every 35 days.
  • CIP-007 — ports and services, security patch evaluation at least every 35 days, malicious code prevention, security event logging and review, and system access controls.
  • CIP-004 — security awareness, cyber security training, personnel risk assessments, and access management, including removing access when people leave.

Moderate and serious risk filings

Most reported noncompliance is minimal risk. The filings that can carry penalties are the moderate and serious risk ones, and there the leading CIP standard changes from period to period.

Sources: 2024 Annual Report Figure 8 (p.18); 2025 Annual Report Figure 8 (p.22); 2026 Mid-Year Report Figure 7 (p.23). Each figure is a top 10 across all standards, so CIP standards outside it are not shown.

  • 2024 — CIP-003: 22 moderate; CIP-007: 21 moderate and 1 serious; CIP-010: 20 and 1; CIP-004: 17 and 1; CIP-002: 8; CIP-005: 8; CIP-014: 6.
  • 2025 — CIP-007: 40; CIP-010: 20; CIP-003: 17; CIP-005: 14; CIP-004: 12; CIP-011: 5. All moderate: the three serious risk filings that year involved operations and planning standards.
  • First half of 2026 — CIP-004: 31 moderate and 7 serious; CIP-010: 13; CIP-007: 7 and 1; CIP-003: 6; CIP-002: 4; CIP-006: 3. NERC gives the root cause of the CIP-004 serious filings as ineffective resource and project planning.

Most noncompliance never becomes a penalty

About 95% of 2024 dispositions, across all standards, were Compliance Exceptions or Find, Fix, Track and Report: methods for minimal and moderate risk issues that involve no settlement agreement or monetary penalty. In 2025 NERC put the split at about 83% Compliance Exceptions and 14% FFT, out of 1,945 dispositions, with 35 (2%) handled through Spreadsheet Notices of Penalty. For the first half of 2026 the CE and FFT share was about 94%.

Self-reporting is the norm: about 87% of noncompliance reported in 2024 was self-identified by the registered entity.

The leading root cause is procedure, not technology

Since late 2024, NERC has assigned Enforcement Cause Codes to dispositions. Of 1,483 CIP dispositions with a code, the most common was lack of or deficient policy or procedure at department or business level (293), followed by ineffective preventive controls (258), additional training needed (158), human performance failure (135) and ineffective validation or detective controls (122). NERC names deficient policy and procedure as the leading root cause of CIP-010, CIP-007 and CIP-004.

Source: 2025 ORCP and CMEP Annual Report, Figure 1 (p.4) and p.20.

What this means for a CIP program

  • Put the effort where the findings are: baselines and change records (CIP-010), patch evaluations and logs (CIP-007), and access and training records (CIP-004).
  • Write the procedure down at the level people actually work, per site and per device type. That is the most common root cause.
  • Find your own issues first. Self-identified, minimal risk issues are usually closed as Compliance Exceptions.
  • Keep dated evidence as you go. Most of these requirements run on 35-day, quarterly or 15-month clocks, and the miss is usually a date.

Download the data

Every number on this page, with the report, figure, page and link it came from.

Sources: NERC 2024 CMEP and ORCP Annual Report (Feb 12, 2025); NERC 2025 ORCP and CMEP Annual Report (Feb 11, 2026); NERC 2026 ORCP and CMEP Mid-Year Report; Second Joint Staff White Paper on Notices of Penalty Pertaining to Violations of CIP Reliability Standards, FERC Docket AD19-18-000 (Sept 23, 2020). All published by NERC and FERC; read November 2026.

Common questions

Which NERC CIP standards are violated most often?

CIP-010 (configuration change management and vulnerability assessments), CIP-007 (system security management) and CIP-004 (personnel and training), in that order, in 2024, 2025 and the first half of 2026, according to NERC's CMEP annual and mid-year reports.

Are NERC CIP penalties public?

No. Since the second joint FERC/NERC staff white paper of September 23, 2020 (Docket AD19-18-000), CIP noncompliance filings are designated CEII in their entirety and NERC no longer posts redacted versions. The entity, the standards violated and the penalty amount are not published.

How often does NERC CIP noncompliance lead to a penalty?

Rarely. About 95% of 2024 dispositions (all standards) were Compliance Exceptions or Find, Fix, Track and Report, which involve no settlement or monetary penalty. In 2025 the split was about 83% Compliance Exceptions and 14% FFT; 35 of 1,945 dispositions (2%) went through Spreadsheet Notices of Penalty.

What is the most common root cause of CIP violations?

Lack of or deficient policy or procedure at department or business level: 293 of 1,483 CIP dispositions with an Enforcement Cause Code, ahead of ineffective preventive controls (258), per NERC's 2025 annual report.

Were there serious risk CIP violations?

Yes in 2024 (one each for CIP-004, CIP-007 and CIP-010) and in the first half of 2026 (eight, involving CIP-004 and CIP-007). In 2025 the three serious risk filings all involved operations and planning standards, not CIP.

General guidance, not legal or compliance advice. Your obligations depend on your registration and assets — confirm them with your compliance team and Regional Entity.

More from Resources